2009-11-14

Ayn Rand and Values

I'm gonna spell it out right off the top: I am heavily prejudiced against Ayn Rand.

If I had to get out all my bad preconceptions of her in one cheap shot, here it is:

"She is a massive cunt who made this bullshit elitist philosophy because she's too much of a whiny, pampered control freak (aka complete bitch) to cope with her childhood 'loss of status' from the middle class. Oh my god, what a tragedy. The bullshit philosophy became a bland, suck-your-cock piece of work that both justified and fed into her mania for the rest of her life. Probably the only thing going for her books is the ridiculous amount of sex. Ugh. Unquote.

...ok, now that the hugely unjustified rant is off my chest, let's talk a bit more nuance.

Now I hate convictions of the reactive rather than the proactive nature, which is part of the reason why I dislike her. However, this makes this post rather ironic given Lisa's recent post, and the fact that I am one of those soulless capitalists doesn't reduce the iron level by much.

Yes, I respect the woman for transforming the philosophical outlook for generations to come. Given the recent interview on Ayn Rand's influence on the daily show, (I don't have the link Canadians can access, but I'm sure you guys can find it) I would say we will probably be soon hitting a resurgence in Objectivism, due to the centre-left president sitting in the White House. I am not going to argue for or against the literal tenets of Objectivism (or the contents of the book), but rather link it up with several other pertinent/dormant themes that occasionally popped up. I might be referring to several of Lisa's posts for content. If you're positions were misstated/misinterpreted, I apologize in advance.

According to our trustworthy wikipedia, Objectivism is:
  1. Reality exists independent of consciousness, and individual persons are in direct contact with this reality through sensory perception
  2. Human beings can gain objective knowledge from perception through the process of concept formation and inductive and deductive logic
  3. Proper moral purpose of one's life is the pursuit of one's own happiness or rational self-interest
  4. The only social system consistent with this morality is full respect for individual rights, embodied in pure laissez faire capitalisms
  5. the role of art in human life is to transform man's widest metaphysical ideas, by selective reproduction of reality, into a physical form—a work of art—that he can comprehend and to which he can respond emotionally
I will talk about 3 and some of 4 here. Some of us interprets these points as a semantical justification for being selfish: after all, isn't the whole point of being altruistic making yourself feel good? Being selfless, in the end, was a reconfirmation of the essence of self, with the individuals closest to you getting the most favours. I don't think I need any more proof as you can all look up yourselves the pyschology studies of the white girl from your hometown compared to millions of starving African children. Some collective consciousness we're tapped into.

Let's suppose this is a valid point. But we've also debated extensively on the role of finance in creating value. Specifically, societal value. What does this have to do with anything? Well, exactly. there is no link even though there should be one. So:

Is creating societal value inherent in the creation of a moral, Objectivist life? Are they distinct and separate domains? And what happens when the a moral, Objectivist life is fully intended to destroy societal value?

Let's avoid the sentimental art rhetoric (#5) for now. I realize that perhaps all objectivist lives, followed properly, is a full artistic expression of that individual's unique awesomeness, but I'm aiming for something a bit more concrete. Consider your average Mongolian raider centuries ago. I firmly believe there is nothing more self-interest oriented than raiding, pillaging, and raping. Satisfies all your needs! Does this expression of manliness and exertion counteract with the thousands of villages and civilization destroyed in the process? Is this a net gain or a net loss for society?

In reverse, and something more recent, being a teacher is extremely strange to me. I've come across this little tidbit on the US News, as well as this. Sure, the potential to breed a future generation of awesome people does sound pretty net-gain to me, but where is the self-interest? Isn't the connection with education bureaucracy a direct edge into collectivist expression (and not even the good type)? Forget about pay, I don't see any sort of personal, self-interest benefit, when you are a teacher. Unless, well, unless you're one of those pedo teachers. Then kudos to you.

What about finance? Let's say I concede defeat on the earlier debates. That finance creates no societal value whatsoever. Financiers, then, are basically modern day barbarians: raid, pillage, rape. Of course, they don't do it excessively (most of the time), otherwise it harms the very system of they are mooching off of. (Now, I can hear a counter-argument in point 4 for respecting the other side's individual rights, but I contend that their rights don't extend to the right to not be legally/legitimately economically squeezed) Probably net loss to society? But naybe they offer indirect benefits? That is, they offer a major history lesson to crucial moments in our civilization? Would the world be a better place if these relatively able people were forced to research cancer cure instead? Would it be a more moral place?

Phrasing the earlier questions conversely: Is creating societal value even necessary in an Objectivist world? Is creating societal value even necessary in this world? Is this a moral obligation?

If I had to condense all this bullshit into one question, it would be this: given some of us had Objectivist influences, why have those specific individuals resented activities that don't create net society gain (howeverly crude that might've been measured?), and instead opt for an activity such as teaching, that did not fully extend her philosophical reasoning into a fully-fledged art form? Is there some self-interest I'm missing?

To me, this is not an issue of provoking the extremes unrelated philosophies. This is a fundamental inconsistency. And inconsistency itches me.

end of entry

P.S. Feel free to reply in your own blogs if comments do not provide enough space. I did. =P

update: thanks for answering my questions! i hope i wasn't being too much of an asshole; to conclude, i'd like to share a nice little tidbit I came across this summer on Ayn Rand

    1 comment:

    Unknown said...

    Please see response: http://a-notebook.blogspot.com/2009/11/ayn-rand-revisited-part-ii.html